APS Raises Concerns Over Proposed NSF Grants Policy Overhaul

Website Banner Black Filler with MS v6
Home / Advocacy & Resources / Science Policy / Federal Research Funding & Policy / APS Raises Concerns Over Proposed NSF Grants Policy Overhaul
Overview 

The National Science Foundation (NSF) proposed a new grants policy document, the Guidance on Financial Assistance (GFA), which would replace the existing Proposal and Award Policies and Procedures Guide (PAPPG). The GFA contains sweeping changes to NSF policies, including aligning with the proposed changes to federal grantmaking proposed by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB), which APS strongly opposes.

Because the proposed OMB grantmaking policy has not yet been finalized and received a strong, overwhelmingly negative response from the public, APS opposes implementation of an NSF policy designed to align with this proposal.

 

Key Concerns from APS 
  • NSF should not adopt proposed OMB rules before they are final. Aligning with the proposed OMB grant rule before it has been finalized is premature and inappropriate. The outcome of the proposed rule has not yet been determined. APS opposes all changes to NSF grant policy that align with the proposed rule.
  • The proposed grant policy changes lack explanation. The proposed GFA includes extensive changes from the existing PAPPG, most of which are inadequately explained. It is unclear why most changes have been made or what impact they would have on researchers.
  • The estimated public burden is wildly inaccurate. The estimated burden to the public provided by NSF does not account for the disastrous impacts on American science that would result from implementing portions of the OMB grantmaking rule.
 
Read the Full APS Comment
The following comments were submitted on behalf of APS

Response to Information Collection 3145-0058: Comment on Draft NSF Guidance on Financial Assistance (NSF-2026-OTR-0001)

The American Physiological Society (APS) appreciates the opportunity to comment on the proposed changes to the National Science Foundation’s (NSF) financial assistance policies incorporated in the draft Guidance on Financial Assistance (GFA). APS is a professional society that is home to more than 8,300 researchers and educators focused on deepening our understanding of living organisms and advancing treatments and cures.

APS strongly opposes the sweeping changes proposed within the draft GFA. The document is tightly interwoven with 2 CFR 200, which is the subject of extensive revisions under a proposal released by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB). As stated in the “Summary of Changes” in the GFA, the document was drafted with a goal of aligning with OMB’s proposed revisions to 2 CFR 200. However, this approach presupposes that these revisions will be implemented in their current form, despite the proposal receiving nearly 500,000 comments, an overwhelming majority of which opposed the changes.[1] NSF should withdraw the draft GFA at least until the outcome of the OMB proposal is determined.

The GFA would replace the Proposal and Award Policies and Procedures Guide (PAPPG), but the new document adds confusion rather than clarity. The brief summary of changes inadequately describes the extensive rewrite of the PAPPG, providing little or no explanation for many of the differences. As a result, it is difficult to identify which changes are intended to align the document with various executive orders or with OMB’s proposed changes to federal grantmaking. The GFA therefore does not give enough information for stakeholders to adequately evaluate its impact. However, aligning the GFA with the proposed changes to 2 CFR 200 will have a detrimental effect on American science.

As APS described in a comment on the OMB proposal, the consequences of implementation would be devastating to American science, innovation and economic growth.[2] Specific concerns include:

  • Peer review is central to U.S. leadership in science. The NSF’s merit review process has been described as an international “gold standard” for review of scientific proposals, relying directly on panels of scientific experts to ensure that scientific merit is the primary basis for funding decisions. OMB proposes a pre-issuance review of every grant by a political appointee, which would erode the quality of federally funded science by allowing vaguely defined political considerations to routinely override peer review.
  • Scientific communication is necessary for progress. Researchers rely on sharing information through peer-reviewed publications and at scientific conferences. Supporting these methods of communication is essential to advancing science. NSF requires researchers to make the published results of their research freely available to the public. It is necessary that researchers have access to adequate funds to publish their work.
  • Expanding authority to terminate awards wastes taxpayer investments. Terminating awards without a right to appeal whenever there is a change in agency priority, which may be as frequent as every time there is a turnover in the presidency, destabilizes the careers of researchers and disrupts ongoing research. This wastes taxpayer money spent on projects that are canceled before they can produce scientific results.
  • International collaboration bolsters U.S. science. Researchers benefit from being able to access international expertise, equipment, reagents and samples. In recent years, federal agencies have taken significant steps to safeguard research security. Additional restrictions on international collaboration will only serve to isolate and diminish U.S. scientists without a clear benefit to national security.

Because the OMB proposal has not been finalized, it is unclear how the GFA will align with the final policy, and it is therefore impossible for the public to fully evaluate the effect of implementing the GFA. However, any changes included in the draft GFA that are based on the proposed changes to 2 CFR 200 will have similar negative consequences as described in the APS comment.

Additionally, the estimated public burden of 120 hours per grant application drastically undercounts the impacts of the proposal. While researchers likely spend far more than 120 hours per grant proposal (it has been estimated that 44.3% of researchers’ time is spent on grant preparation and administration[3]), the estimate also fails to consider the public burden of lost scientific progress, delayed cures and treatments, and stifled economic growth. The impacts of the sweeping changes proposed in the GFA cannot be simply calculated as a number of hours.

APS urges NSF to withdraw NSF-2026-OTR-0001 at a minimum until the outcome of proposed changes to 2 CFR 200 is finalized. The draft GFA presupposes that this highly contested proposal will be finalized in its current form, disregarding the staggering opposition the proposal has received from the scientific community. Furthermore, the GFA adds confusion by making broad changes to the language of the PAPPG without a clear explanation of each change and without explaining how it aligns with proposed changes to 2 CFR 200. APS encourages NSF to provide a full explanation of any changes to its grants policy, and to provide a more thorough impact analysis for these changes.

[1] https://www.aip.org/fyi/proposed-grantmaking-reforms-prompt-huge-negative-response

[2] https://www.physiology.org/detail/news/2026/07/07/aps-submits-formal-comments-opposing-proposed-omb-grant-rule?SSO=Y

[3] https://thefdp.org/wp-content/uploads/FDP-FWS-2018-Primary-Report.pdf

 

Why It Matters

The proposed OMB revisions to the Guidance for Federal Financial Assistance would have devastating consequences to American science by politicizing funding decisions, hindering scientific communication and progress, impeding publication and undermining research integrity, destabilizing the careers of talented and innovative researchers, and putting in place overly restrictive barriers to international collaboration. The draft GFA would implement some of these changes for grants issued by NSF, with similar consequences to NSF-funded research.

 

 

 

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience. Privacy Policy

OK